Reinier Kruisbrink

Cover of The Tech Coup
The Tech Coup
How to Save Democracy from Silicon Valley
Marietje Schaake
Read: 2025
My Rating: 8/10
In De Tech Coup, Marietje Schaake, a former Member of European Parliament and current Stanford policy expert, critically examines the increasing power and influence of major tech companies and how their largely unregulated dominance poses significant risks to democracy, privacy, and societal well-being.

3 min read

De Tech Coup: How to Save Democracy from Silicon Valley

Overview

Marietje Schaake, former Member of European Parliament and Stanford cyber-policy fellow, argues that the world’s largest technology companies have accumulated power that rivals and in some domains exceeds that of nation-states, controlling critical infrastructure, shaping public discourse, conducting surveillance, and operating across borders with minimal democratic oversight. The book examines how this concentration of power emerged, why existing regulatory frameworks have failed to contain it, and what governance structures would be needed to realign technology with democratic values. Schaake draws on her legislative experience with the EU’s digital regulation efforts to propose concrete policy interventions.

Key Concepts

The Accumulation of Tech Power

  • Platform monopolies: network effects, data advantages, and acquisition strategies have enabled a handful of companies (Google, Meta, Amazon, Apple, Microsoft) to dominate markets in search, social media, cloud computing, and mobile ecosystems, creating chokepoints with few competitive alternatives
  • Infrastructural power: tech firms now operate critical infrastructure (cloud servers hosting government data, submarine cables, payment systems, app stores) that gives them leverage over governments, businesses, and individuals who depend on their services
  • Informational asymmetry: platforms possess vastly more data about citizens than governments do, enabling microtargeted advertising, behavioural prediction, and content curation at a scale that reshapes public opinion without transparency

Threats to Democracy

  • Algorithmic amplification: engagement-optimised recommendation algorithms systematically amplify emotionally charged, divisive, and sensational content because it generates more clicks, undermining informed public discourse and polarising electorates
  • Surveillance capitalism: the core business model of many platforms, extracting behavioural data to sell prediction products to advertisers, creates pervasive surveillance infrastructure that can be repurposed by authoritarian governments or exploited in data breaches
  • Private governance of speech: content moderation decisions (what speech is permitted, what is removed, who is banned) are made by corporate employees using opaque rules, with no democratic mandate, judicial review, or meaningful appeal process

Regulatory Failures and Proposals

  • The EU as regulatory pioneer: Schaake discusses the GDPR, Digital Services Act, Digital Markets Act, and AI Act as attempts to impose democratic governance on tech, noting both their ambitions and their implementation challenges
  • Antitrust and interoperability: breaking up monopolies or mandating interoperability (allowing users to switch platforms without losing data or connections) would reduce lock-in and restore competitive dynamics
  • Transparency and accountability: mandatory algorithmic audits, researcher access to platform data, and independent oversight bodies would make corporate decision-making visible and contestable
  • International coordination: because tech companies operate globally, national regulation alone is insufficient; Schaake advocates for transatlantic and multilateral frameworks to prevent regulatory arbitrage

Personal Reflection

It is quite a different book than what I normally read, yet at the same time more in my own area of formal expertise. The book describes many of the issues that we, as humanity, are aware of, and points out that getting technology governance right is crucial as it is challenging. But that challenge is necessary to ensure that technology serves democratic values rather than undermining them. I think most of the books I mention below share a similar concern with the societal impact of unchecked growth and the need for thoughtful governance, and how the industry itself tries to influence the debate and regulatory landscape.

Parent: Books

Graph View