The Strange Order of Things: Life, Feeling, and the Making of Cultures

Overview

“The Strange Order of Things” by Antonio Damasio proposes a radical rethinking of consciousness, arguing that feelings are the foundational layer upon which minds, consciousness, and culture are built.

Key Concepts

Damasio posits that consciousness didn’t suddenly appear with complex brains but rather evolved gradually from basic homeostatic mechanisms. He argues that the earliest forms of “mind” were feelings.

The Origin of Feelings

Homeostasis The fundamental state of life regulation, maintaining stable internal conditions, through genetic programs and chemistry.

Nerves From the original nerve nets in simple organisms like hydras, to the dense network of nerves around your gut, and the evolution from ancient to modern nervous systems—these are the biological substrates for sensing and regulating the body.

Affect The raw, non-conscious physiological changes that occur in the body in response to stimuli, which are the precursors to feelings. These are the immediate bodily reactions that then get translated into a subjective experience.

Feelings The first form of consciousness, arising when the brain creates a subjective mental representation of the body’s homeostatic state and its physiological changes.

Recursive Emotive Loop As nervous systems became more advanced, the brain began responding not only to external stimuli, but also to its own affective outputs. For example, an initial reaction to danger (like increased heart rate or muscle tension) can be sensed again and interpreted as stress or anxiety—a second-order feeling. This loop—feeling a reaction, reacting to that feeling, and then feeling that reaction again—allowed the emergence of increasingly layered emotional experiences such as guilt, anticipation, embarrassment, and existential dread. These recursive emotional states represent the beginnings of emotional self-awareness, where the organism not only reacts to the world but also reacts to itself.

Sensing and Learning

Interoception Visceral/chemical sensing, providing information about the body’s internal state (e.g., hunger, pain, comfort).

Proprioception Musculoskeletal sensing, offering awareness of the body’s position and movement in space, but also e.g. direction of the eyes through the eyeball socket, that might function as metadata to create the “I” perspective of subjectivity.

Exteroception Sensory portals (vision, hearing, smell, taste, touch) that provide information about the external environment.

Correlation The continuous correlation between interoception (internal bodily states) and proprioception/exteroception (external world and body in space) allows organisms to constantly measure and correlate the state of life regulation with the surroundings. This feedback loop is vital for learning and refining adaptive behaviors, ensuring survival and well-being.

Consciousness and Cultures

Subjectivity The unique, first-person “what it’s like” experience that emerges from the brain’s integrated representations of interoceptive and exteroceptive data, with proprioception acting as a sort of “metadata” providing context for the body’s interaction with the world.

Feeling Feelings For feelings to have an impact and drive behavior, they must be “felt” or consciously experienced by the organism. This conscious awareness of our internal states is what allows them to affect our decisions, learning, and overall life regulation, and drive creative intelligence and cultures.

Cultures Consciousness, driven by the imperative to regulate life and optimize feelings, leads to the creation of complex cultures—our collective efforts to improve well-being, manage suffering, and create a more stable and flourishing existence.

Personal Reflection

Overall an incredibly interesting book, but written in a very dense and academic style (sometimes too much for my taste). Damasio’s exploration of the evolution of consciousness and the role of feelings in shaping our minds and cultures is a thought-provoking journey that challenges traditional views of consciousness as a mere byproduct of complex brain activity. He emphasizes the importance of understanding our emotional lives as a foundation for navigating the complexities of existence, and how this understanding can lead to a more compassionate and interconnected world.

Related Books

• Looking for Spinoza - Damasío’s earlier work on emotions; this book broadens the canvas to homeostasis and culture
• Feeling & Knowing - Damasío distils the consciousness argument he builds up here
• The Hidden Spring - Solms offers an alternative affect-based consciousness theory that dialogues with Damasío’s

---

Parent: Books